Skip to content

Make a Payment by Phone

There are two ways to pay over the phone:

  1. Call 1-800-283-3531 for a customer service representative – Pay during our regular business hours from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., Monday through Friday, with personal assistance from one of our customer service representatives. Dial toll-free 1-800-283-3531 and ask for the billing department. Our representatives can accept a payment from your bank account; a debit card with a MasterCard or Visa logo; or a MasterCard or Visa credit card. Please have your policy number and payment information ready when you call.
  2. Call 888-505-0153 to use our interactive voice response system – Pay your premium 24/7, evenings, weekends, and holidays, by using our interactive voice response (IVR) payment system. Have your policy/account number available and dial 888-505-0153. Follow the system’s prompts to complete your payment using an electronic check from a checking or savings account; a debit card bearing a MasterCard or Visa logo; or a MasterCard or Visa credit card. (Pennsylvania commercial customers please note: You will be charged a convenience fee of $7.95 when using the IVR system.)

Prefer not to call? 
Make a payment online or schedule automatic recurring payments from your bank account.

Make a Payment by Mail

Please send your payment along with your remittance stub to:

Accounting Department
Mutual Benefit Group
409 Penn Street
PO Box 577
Huntingdon, PA 16652-0577

Wish you didn’t have to dig out the checkbook and the stamps? 
Make a payment online or schedule recurring payments from your bank account.

Coverage/product information provided on this Web site is not an insurance policy or a supplement to any policy. This information is intended to provide a general description of products typically available through Mutual Benefit Insurance Company and Select Risk Mutual Insurance Company. The actual coverage provided is governed exclusively by the language contained within the insurance policy issued to you.